A Fighting Chance?
Defense Dept. Cashes In On Overseas Slot Machines While Problem Gambling Among Military Personnel Is Largely Undiagnosed
In August 2018, President Trump signed into law the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA), to fund the nation’s military operations for the 2019 fiscal year. It includes a provision that has been absent for about 15 years: required problem-gambling screening for members of the Armed Forces.
The National Council on Problem Gambling (NCPG) says about 56,000 active-duty military personnel are problem gamblers out of more than a million service men and women. The Department of Defense (DoD) reports about 120 active military sought treatment in 2017. About 10 percent of veterans using Veterans Affairs services are problem gamblers, according to the NCPG.
[Problem Gambling is] gambling behavior patterns that compromise, disrupt or damage personal, family or vocational pursuits. Characterized by an increasing preoccupation with gambling, a need to bet more money more frequently, restlessness or irritability when attempting to stop, and “chasing” losses.National Council on Problem Gambling
Members of the Armed Forces serving overseas don’t have far to look to find ways to gamble. There are about 2,000 slot machines (not 3,000 as some have reported) on more than 60 overseas bases. The DoD generates $100 million each year from active-duty military personnel playing on those slot machines.
None of the money goes toward problem-gambling treatment.
Who serves? There are 1.2 million active-duty military. Racial and ethnic minority groups make up 40 percent of active-duty military.Department of Defense
Jessica Maxwell, a spokesperson for the office of the Secretary of Defense, said the slot machines “are provided on military installations overseas as recreational options to eligible morale, welfare and recreation patrons (active duty, family members, DoD civilians, and foreign national civilians). Revenues are returned to programs to support other recreational activities.”
Stateside bases removed slot machines in the 1950s, but bingo is played on 72 out of approximately 418 stateside bases, Maxwell said.
“It’s clear that the Department of Defense in some ways is a large casino operator, given that they have thousands of slot machines on our overseas bases in addition to a tremendous amount of on-post bingo throughout the continental United States,” said Keith Whyte, NCPG executive director.
Screening questions to detect problem gambling in the military were discontinued in the early 2000s. The NCPG has lobbied ever since to restore those questions, because military personnel tend to be at greater risk for problem gambling than some other groups.
Maxwell contradicted the assertion about risk and said screening questions were discontinued “because the prevalence of the condition in the military population was low.”
The screening questions are back now, in part, said Maxwell, because “problem gambling often heralds other treatable addictions and mental-health conditions. Additionally, problem gambling is a security threat inasmuch as sufferers could be compromised by adversaries.”
Today, about 2 million, or 1 percent of adults, in the U.S. are estimated to meet the criteria for pathological (severe) gambling. Another 4 million to 6 million would be considered problem gamblers.
About 2 percent of active military personnel meet the criteria for problem gambling.
“The other important part of screening is that unlike substance abuse or other disorders that have more outward physical signs, gambling addiction is what we often call the hidden addiction,” Whyte said.
Why is Gambling Addictive? Gambling can stimulate the brain's reward system much like drugs or alcohol can, leading to addiction. Exactly what causes someone to gamble compulsively isn't well-understood. Like many problems, compulsive gambling may result from a combination of biological, genetic and environmental factors.Mayo Clinic
He said because the military stopped screening, a whole generation has gone undiagnosed and untreated. And military personnel often suffer in silence.
“They don’t want to lose their security clearance,” Whyte said. “They may not even know that what they have is a treatable disorder. A lot of people from the outside think it’s simply bad money management, or you’re immoral for gambling in the first place, or you’re weak because you can’t stop.”
These concerns and others — including separation from a unit or fear if a crime has been committed because of gambling — are reasons the addiction goes unreported in many cases.
Whyte and other advocates say veterans also have higher rates of problem gambling than the rest of the the population. In 2012, he penned a letter to then-U.S. Veterans Affairs leader Secretary Eric Shinseki:
“Gambling addiction is a serious health problem that affects veterans and active duty service members. It is highly co-occurring with other serious conditions and complicates the treatment of those disorders,” the letter reads.
“Despite overwhelming evidence that pathological gambling is common and serious complicating comorbidity, veterans seeking mental health or substance abuse care in VHA are not generally screened for gambling problems nor has problem gambling been integrated into substance use disorder, co-occurring disorder or mental health treatment programs.”
The NDAA provision for screening does not include veterans.
On The Front Lines
Marcena Gunter, a spokeswoman for Veterans Affairs (VA), said internet gambling also gives overseas Armed Forces members easy access to gaming. Once they leave the military, many veterans the agency works with become addicted to video slot machines. Homeless veterans appear to be more addicted to scratch-off games and the lottery, she said.
One counseling service that helps gambling addict who are veterans and active military is the Life Crisis Center housed at Provident, Inc., in St. Louis.
People struggling with various mental-health issues can call the 24-hour hotline for free counseling over the telephone. The hotline is funded partially through money provided by the state’s gaming commission.
Missouri spends an average of 4 cents per capita, or $258,000 a year, on services and treatment for problem gambling. The national average is 37 cents per capita.2016 Survey of Problem Gambling Services in the United States
The center receives hundreds of calls a day that come through Missouri’s 1‑888BetsOff hotline, run by an alliance of public agencies. By one Friday afternoon in early October, the center’s counselors had answered 77 calls since midnight. That’s about six calls an hour.
Clinician Jessica Vance pointed to her computer screen to show the questions counselors ask, including whether callers are at risk for suicide. According to the Nevada Council on Problem Gambling, up to half of people in treatment for problem-gambling disorder have thought about suicide and about 17 percent attempted it.
“We try to assess for suicide on as many gambling calls as possible, because that is often symptomatic of struggling with a gambling addiction,” Vance said. “And I don’t know the stats on the portion of our gambling callers who are veterans, but I would say that it is a good chunk of them.”
The clinicians at Provident who handle calls from problem gamblers said one of the biggest hurdles for callers is shame. They say callers struggle to understand that gambling is a valid addiction similar to other substance-abuse problems.
“Maybe there is some traumatic history, maybe something horrible that they witnessed in the line of duty,” Vance said. “But sometimes it’s not the case. Sometimes people just gamble because it’s fun. It’s legal. It’s a stress release. Sometimes it’s something people do to cope with loneliness, and then it can just snowball out of control and turn into an addiction.”
It took about a decade for lawmakers and the federal government to turn their attention to problem gambling among active military personnel.
In 2015, the Senate adopted an amendment introduced by Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) requiring the Government Accountability Office (GAO) to produce a study on problem gambling in the military.
Two years later, the GAO released this report, which shed light on the fact that there are thousands of slot machines on military installations overseas, yet the DoD doesn’t systematically screen military personnel for gambling disorder. The GAO recommended that the DoD incorporate questions on gambling disorder in its annual health assessments and DoD-wide surveys.
In June of 2017, Warren introduced the Preventing and Treating Gambling Disorder in the Military Act of 2017, which would require the DoD to screen servicemembers for gambling disorder and include gambling disorder in certain surveys.
This provision didn’t make it into the Senate version of the 2018 NDAA. In 2018, Warren tried again, working with Sen. Ted Daines (R-MT) to introduce a new bill, the Gambling Addiction Prevention Act, which included the provision to require DoD to screen and survey servicemembers for gambling disorders, as well as a new provision requiring the DoD to develop policies and programs to prevent and treat gambling problems. This measure made it into the 2019 NDAA which passed and was signed by the president.
In November, Warren questioned Thomas McCaffery, nominee to be assistant secretary of defense for health affairs, about the matter of problem gambling and the military.
Referring to the overseas slot machines, she asked, “Do you think it’s a good idea to have slots on these bases to fund other recreational activities?”
McCaffery said he was unaware of the slot machines on bases but pledged to give his attention to the matter and how it “links to some of [Sen. Warren’s] concerns regarding gambling disorder.” He then committed to enforcing the NDAA provision.
Whyte of the NCPG would like to see the government go even further.
“Our call (in addition to screening) is just that they devote some of that money to making sure that, again, their own troops and their dependents have adequate and effective prevention education and treatment,” Whyte said. “It’s a simple proposition if you operate in profit from gambling, you need to minimize harm.”