© 2023 St. Louis Public Radio
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

What it’s like to audition for the St. Louis Muny

Ever thought about trying out for America's oldest, largest outdoor theater?

Each year, the 98-year-old St. Louis Muny holds open auditions; anyone can come. Singers and dancers try out on different weekends. Males and females audition separately. For 18-year-old Lydia Berry, a recent audition was a chance to see if she’s ready for the professional dance world.

Will "100" be Lydia Berry's lucky number?
Credit The Muny
Will "100" be Lydia Berry's lucky number?

When the Creve Coeur ballerina arrived, dozens of other dancers were already there, bending their legs back over their heads and doing other impossible-looking stretches inside Webster University’s dance studios. But when Berry got her number, she felt lucky, not late.

“Oh wow, I’m number 100. Woohoo! I’m really glad I got here when I did,” Berry said.

Will she make the cut?

Berry’s wearing her lucky purple hairband and favorite orange leotard. She’s also sporting one fluorescent green sock and another orange-and-pink one embellished with hot dogs.

Lydia Berry, in her mix-matched socks, warms up with a friend.
Credit The Muny
Lydia Berry, in her mix-matched socks, warms up with a friend.

“I think mix-match shows my personality in my feet,” Berry said. “So that people are like, ‘Oh, look at her, she’s not coordinated, she’s not normal, she’s funky, she likes to break out of the box.’”

Berry also stands out as one of only a half dozen African Americans out of a total of 200 dancers. But she’s typical of this crowd in many other ways, dancing practically since she could walk. Her single mother, an attorney, has been a driving force, tallying up untold hours in driving her daughter to class, spending hundreds, maybe thousands, of dollars every year for outfits, shoes and lessons.

“I love my mom and she loves me,” Berry said. “But, sometimes I’m like, ‘Mom, leave me alone!’ Just typical, but at the end of the day she’s been my support.”

But Lydia’s on her own after the starting signal, a tingling bell followed by an announcement that it’s time to begin.

And just like in the musical “A Chorus Line,” they all line up by number. When you’ve grow up performing, that play is like your bible. Lydia gives in to my request to sing a well-known lyric describing what everyone here is feeling.

“Please, God I need this job,” she laughs.

After learning a quick combination, it's time to perform for the judges. Megan Larche Dominick – who actually cast the Broadway revival of “A Chorus Line” – is now the Muny’s casting director.

“I like to see personality, so I like to see people who, even though it’s really difficult, can get out of their head and smile,” Dominick said.

Lydia Berry (forefront) wearing her favorite orange leotard.
Credit The Muny
Lydia Berry (forefront) wearing her favorite orange leotard.

Now it’s Lydia’s turn to show them what she’s got. And she does smile, but not in an over-the-top way like some do. She seems relaxed and confident.

The judges include Muny executive producer Mike Isaacson, who snacks on a banana. They have precious little time to study each dancer. Only minutes after the final group performs, their decisions are made.

“If I don’t call your name, you’re all done for today. Thank you so much for your hard work,” the announcer said, before reading her list of the chosen ones, which begins with …. “Lydia Berry.”

“I’m feeling really happy!” Berry said, out of breath from the anticipation. “I’m feeling good, feeling excited.”

Afterward, more dancing, until nearly 9 p.m.  Then more waiting, at home.  But just at hour later she gets the email calling her back for the next day. Lydia’s longtime instructor Alvin Ailey dancer Alicia Graf Mack is not surprised.

Alicia Graf Mack and Antonio Douthit-Boyd
Credit Richard Calmes
File photo of Alicia Graf Mack and Antonio Douthit-Boyd

“She has all the elements of someone who’s an exciting performer. She also has a background in theater,” Mack said. “So I feel like she is a complete artist; when you watch her perform your eye is drawn to her.”

Two more weeks of waiting

But will Lydia’s ability be enough to win a role at the Muny this season? Mack said every dancer, even professionals like herself, has areas to work on. For Lydia, it’s about control.

“She does have so much raw power that sometimes we have to tone it down a little bit,” Mack said.

“Waiting is the hardest part,”singer Tom Petty crooned, famously. 

That’s something veteran Muny performer Cara Salerno knows well. She’s been auditioning for the Muny since 1997. Waiting at the same tryouts as Berry, Salerno calmly listened to music in her earphones and ate yogurt.

Cara Salerno
Credit The Muny
Cara Salerno

“A lot of it is to let go of the pressure and go in and have fun,” Salerno said. “Then, just walk away, feeling like you’ve done your best.”

Salerno’s still waiting to see if she’s booked a Muny show this summer. Not everyone finds out at the same time and she’s not sure how long it will be.

Berry waited two weeks. In the meantime, she concentrated on schoolwork. She’s finishing a two-year community college degree in theater and is set to attend Missouri Baptist this fall. She got an early start in college at the age of 16, thanks to a home-school organization and her signature ability to buckle down and focus.

But this time, her grit and talent wouldn’t be enough. After 14 days, the Muny’s answer was “no.” Sometimes that decision can hinge on a detail as small as an available costume or the need for a dancer of a certain height. It may have nothing to do with talent. Berry was disappointed but philosophical.

“Just making it to the callbacks, alone, shows I have what it takes,” Berry said. “And with a little more hard work and determination, I can make it be whatever I want. I can do whatever I put my mind to.”

Berry's ultimate goal is to become an Ailey dancer. In the meantime, she’ll keep dancing with St. Louis' Big Muddy Dance Company, and try out again for the Muny next year. And she’s still got one more chance at a professional role this summer, at Stages St. Louis. Berry hopes to hear about the results of that audition any day now.

Follow Nancy Fowler on Twitter: @NancyFowlerSTL

Nancy is a veteran journalist whose career spans television, radio, print and online media. Her passions include the arts and social justice, and she particularly delights in the stories of people living and working in that intersection.

Send questions and comments about this story to feedback@stlpublicradio.org.